Port Fairy pool frequently asked questions

Overview

The closure of Port Fairy Pool has been disappointing for many people in our community and we recognise the important role the facility has played in local life.

We understand residents have questions about why the facility closed, the decisions that followed and what the future may hold for aquatic facilities in Moyne Shire.

We've answered some of the most frequently asked questions that we have received below and will continue to share information as work progresses.

Why was Port Fairy Pool closed?

Belfast Aquatics, the organisation responsible for managing the facility, made the decision to close Port Fairy Pool on 21 November 2025 after mould and algae were identified throughout the building. The reported extent of the contamination raised serious public health and safety concerns. Council supported the closure in light of those reported risks.

Why can't Council simply repair the pool and reopen it?

Council understands why many community members would like to see the existing facility repaired and reopened. However, the independent technical investigation identified significant problems with the building's structure, pool shell, plant and equipment, and other essential infrastructure.

Addressing these issues would require extensive work, with considerable cost, risk and uncertainty about whether the facility could be returned to a reliable, fit-for-purpose standard over the long term.

At its May 2026 meeting, Council considered the findings and unanimously resolved to decommission and remove the facility. Based on the technical advice, a repair-based solution was not considered a viable long-term option.

How much would it cost to repair the existing pool?

The technical assessments identified that substantial work would be required to address the facility's condition and bring it up to an appropriate operating standard. The projected costs would extend well beyond repairing just the visible damage. Work would also be required to address structural issues, the pool shell, plant and equipment, building services and relevant safety and compliance requirements.

Council's assessment was that a repair-based solution would involve considerable cost and uncertainty, without providing the community with sufficient confidence that the facility could operate reliably over the long term.

Why is Council proceeding with demolition if a replacement pool has not been approved?

The decision about the existing building is separate from the question of future aquatic facilities in Moyne Shire. The technical investigation found that repairing the existing facility was not a viable long-term option, and Council resolved to decommission and remove it in May 2026.

Demolition will allow Council to address the future of the site while continuing to investigate options for aquatic facilities through its Aquatic Facilities Strategy. Council has not committed to building a replacement pool at this time. Any future proposal will firstly need to be supported by a feasibility study, which has now received funding, as well as a clear understanding of community needs, an assessment of costs and ongoing operating requirements, and a viable funding approach. 

Who managed the facility?

Port Fairy Pool and Fitness Centre was managed by the Belfast Aquatics Committee of Management from its opening in 2007 until the facility closed. Although Council owns the land and provided funding to support the facility, it was not a Council-operated facility.

Under the occupation agreement between Council and the Belfast Aquatics Committee of Management, responsibility for maintenance rested with the committee. This agreement set out the respective responsibilities of Council and the committee during the facility's operation.

Did Council contribute funding to the facility?

Yes. Council provided more than $3 million in funding to support the facility since it opened in 2007, including $290,000 in the 2024–25 financial year.

Council has always recognised the facility's importance to the community and has contributed funding to support it over many years.

What problems were identified at the facility?

Over time, the building's components and essential plant and equipment deteriorated. This contributed to concerns about the building's condition and safety, as well as the development of mould.

The issues extended beyond the building's appearance. The condition of the pool, its supporting infrastructure and its equipment raised questions about safety, compliance, repair requirements and the feasibility of returning the facility to operation.

What happened to the gym and fitness facilities?

The pool and fitness centre closed in November 2025 after mould and algae were identified throughout the building. The technical investigations identified concerns affecting the wider building, not just the pool area. Because the contamination and associated building issues could not be isolated to the swimming area, reopening the gym separately was not considered appropriate.

Council's public health and safety obligations apply to the facility as a whole. The gym therefore could not simply reopen while the wider building remained affected.

Were the reports commissioned by Council provided to the committee?

Yes. Council provided the reports it commissioned to the Belfast Aquatics Committee of Management, both by email and in hard copy. The committee also commissioned reports of its own. These reports formed part of the information available to the parties as they considered the facility's condition and its future.

Was Council transparent in its decision-making?

Some discussions and information could not be made public because of confidentiality requirements under the Local Government Act 2020. Council must comply with these legal requirements when dealing with confidential matters.

However, Council understands that confidentiality can make it harder for the community to follow the decision-making process. Where information can lawfully be shared, Council will continue to provide updates and explain the decisions made and the reasons behind them.

Will Council commit to building a new pool?

Council cannot commit to building a new pool at this stage. Before a decision can be made, Council needs a clearer understanding of the options, potential locations, costs, operating requirements and likely benefits to the community.

Council has welcomed $40,000 in Victorian Government funding towards a feasibility study and business case for a potential new indoor aquatic facility in Moyne Shire. This will complement Council's existing $80,000 commitment.

The work is an immediate priority identified in Council's Aquatics Facilities Strategy 2026–2036, adopted in June 2026. It will help establish what may be feasible and provide a stronger evidence base for future decisions.

While this work is an important step, it does not mean a new facility has been approved or that funding for its construction has been secured. Council will share further information as the study progresses and decisions are made.

What will happen to the land where the Port Fairy Pool is located?

The land is owned by Council and is zoned for public purpose and recreation. Council has no plans to use the site for an alternative purpose at this stage. 

The immediate focus is on progressing the necessary preparations for demolition. Any future decisions about the site's use will be communicated to the community.

Could the existing facility be converted into an outdoor pool?

Unfortunately, the existing facility cannot simply be converted into an outdoor pool.

An asset audit identified significant condition, safety and compliance issues affecting the pool shell, plant and equipment, and surrounding infrastructure. Removing the building alone would not resolve these issues. An outdoor pool would still require substantial design work, infrastructure, safety and compliance assessments, and operational planning. These additional requirements mean converting the existing facility into an outdoor pool is not considered a viable option.

We recognise that an outdoor pool may seem like a simpler alternative, but the technical and infrastructure requirements mean it cannot be treated as a straightforward conversion.

Will Port Fairy ever have another pool?

Council has committed to investigating the potential for a new indoor aquatic facility through the Moyne Aquatic Facilities Strategy 2026–2036.

The Victorian Government has committed $40,000 towards a feasibility study and business case, complementing Council's existing $80,000 commitment. The study will investigate community demand, potential locations, the services a facility could provide, construction costs and ongoing operating requirements.

This work will help Council understand whether a new facility is feasible and what would be required to deliver and sustain it. While investigating future options is an important step, it’s important to state that a new pool has not been approved and construction funding has not been secured. Council will share the findings and explain the next steps as the work progresses.

What other aquatic facilities can residents use?

Moyne Shire Council operates outdoor swimming pools in Hawkesdale, Macarthur and Mortlake. These facilities provide alternative seasonal options for swimming and recreation.

Residents can find information about locations, opening hours and available facilities through Council's swimming pools webpage.